Democratic Structures NOT In Name Only
Or What We Hold in Common is More than What Divides Us
By Sarah Meredith, SCDC Gilboa Rep
Democrats hold all manner of opinions about a wide variety of subjects and policies. Few political parties or segments of the voting public are monolithic in their beliefs. Yet, there are key shared structures that define democracy for Democrats here in upstate New York:
1. That voting is a sacred right and the capacity to vote ought to be accessible to all citizens.
2. That the Constitution is the foundation of the laws of our nation, not a personality or political party, and that the law ought to apply equally to all people, regardless of particular attributes.
3. That religious freedom is a defining aspect of our Constitution, requiring that all specific religions be kept separate from operating the government.
4. That unbiased public education is a necessity and relies upon national standards to ensure equality of opportunity and commonly held norms of our times.
5. That non-politicized health care for everyone, and the capacity to access it, is imperative for economic growth and social stability, requiring that some governmental steps be taken to ensure quality of care and more universally available health care.
6. That science, technology, history and the arts have fact-based components that can be subject to interpretation yet form the premise for human endeavor and future growth.
7. That natural resources upon which we all rely need protection and regulation to prevent greed and inequality from doing irreparable damage to people and the planet, and that federal, state and local governments have a role to play in helping industry and communities use these resources wisely.
8. That essential services are the support network for our nation, such as safe food production, legitimate medical care, fact-based education, resources for the very young, elderly, disabled, public safety, legal services, environmental safeguards, workplace safety, public transportation, worker protections, secure childcare and more, and are partially the responsibility of national standards, monitoring and funding.
9. That federal level diplomatic relationships be maintained throughout the world, and that our resources are necessary to support democracy, environmental protection, sound business and scientific practices and reduction of harm and military conflict.
10. That all people are created equal with inalienable rights, and by definition this extends to an ever wider application of protection under our laws.
11. That persons in this country have rights to privacy, including choice in their families, medical options, religious beliefs, and personal associations, and that such rights are protected privileges of living in this country as differing from most other places on earth.
12. That all but the American indigenous peoples are relative newcomers to this land, none with greater claim on the rights and privileges of democracy , and that the humane and rational resolution of conflict over the continuation of immigration and migration, whether permanent or temporary, is of primary importance to the nation’s growth and health.
13. That use of fossil fuels and emissions of methane (among other pollutants) must be reduced dramatically as urgently as possible in order to maintain the balance of resources necessary for sustaining communities and biological health for myriad species, including humans, and that federal, state and local governments have a role to play in making this happen along with assisting communities in making the transitions and retrofitting required.
14. That participatory democracy is a work in progress, representing the highest form of imperfect government, and requires continuous amendment and refinement to meet the needs of contemporary and future society.
15. That ideals and principles guide this nation, not individuals, and that all of us hold some accountability and responsibility for working on the details within our own families, communities, and local political units.
16. That the peaceful transfer of power is the result of our elections, not mob rule, violence and censorship, and our elections rely on a combination of federal and state rules enforced at the polls primarily by citizen volunteers.
Each of these 16 statements has a network of impacts, implications and actions about which we can agree or disagree. For example, even the first one about voting might raise a variety of opinions about mail-in ballots or whether or not felons, who have served their time, can register to vote or if automatic registration at the DMV is a good idea, etc.
As an exercise, you might take a minute and make a list of what you see as the most obvious areas of discussion or argument related to each of these points. You could be a Democrat, who, when considering #5 believes that legal abortion is best limited to within a specific number of weeks except for medical necessities as seen between a pregnant person, their family and their doctor, or that abortion services are medical services that ought not be limited by any governmental legislature. You might be a Democrat, who, in considering #11 thinks that the filibuster that prevents a simple majority from passing legislation is a good thing, or that it allows minority rule to prevail and ought to be abolished. In a democracy we can agree to disagree on specifics of policy while still supporting the fundamentals of DEMOCRACY itself.
It might help us approach this election year, in which there are people who may not see their votes as destructive of democracy, to see where our interests actually align. We will be spending a fair amount of energy trying to persuade our fellow citizens to vote for anyone other than a MAGA Republican. What Democrats understand is that Trump does not value the Constitution or the law if they constrain his will; and his priorities are not equality and inclusion, but retribution and spoils to the victor by any means necessary. If we Democrats can see more of a range of possible positions and beliefs that still fall under these 16 points, it could be easier to sustain disagreements about details that do not pit us against each other.
Some of our Republican neighbors might take different positions on specific policies but STILL SUPPORT THESE VALUES. Highlighting this will make conversations more persuasive and productive.
There is so much at stake this year. These 16 points are not an exhaustive list. Perhaps you can come up with other basic statements that support democracy and undergird what we hold in common. If we can help our neighbors see our mutually held beliefs, we might prevent our U.S. government from becoming a democracy in name only.